You submitted ‘Validate Fix’ for a resolved ‘Server error (5xx)’ issue, but it failed validation again. What are your next steps?
If the ‘Validate Fix’ submission for a resolved Server error (5xx) failed again in Google Search Console (GSC), here's how to troubleshoot and resolve it systematically:
🔁 1. Confirm the Issue Still Exists
🔍 Re-check the Affected URLs
-
Use tools like
curl
, browser DevTools, or uptime monitors to:-
Test the HTTP response (
curl -I https://example.com/problem-url
) -
Verify if 5xx errors (e.g., 500, 502, 503, 504) are still being returned.
-
-
Try accessing the URL:
-
As a logged-out user.
-
From different geolocations or using Googlebot User-Agent.
-
🧪 Use Google’s URL Inspection Tool
-
Input the URL in Search Console.
-
Click "Test Live URL" to get real-time results.
-
See if the live version is still returning a 5xx error.
🗂 2. Check Server Logs and Monitoring
-
Review web server logs (Apache/Nginx) and application logs.
-
Look for:
-
Stack traces
-
Timeout errors
-
Resource exhaustion (CPU/memory)
-
Configuration errors (e.g., .htaccess, PHP memory limits)
-
🔁 3. Identify Patterns or Triggers
-
Are all errors from the same:
-
CMS module?
-
Time of day (suggesting load issues)?
-
Bot traffic (e.g., Googlebot, Bingbot)?
-
-
Check if Cloudflare, load balancers, or firewall rules are interfering.
🛠 4. Fix the Root Cause
-
Common fixes may include:
-
Increasing memory/time limits
-
Fixing broken database queries
-
Resolving circular redirects
-
Restarting overloaded services
-
Reverting unstable CMS plugins or themes
-
🧪 5. Retest Before Resubmitting
-
Manually test a sample of affected URLs.
-
Use a tool like:
-
Screaming Frog (set to list mode)
-
HTTP status checker (bulk testing)
-
-
Test using Googlebot user-agent if needed.
✅ 6. Resubmit for Validation Again
-
Once you’re confident the issue is fixed for all affected URLs, go to GSC:
-
Select the error (e.g., “Server error (5xx)”)
-
Click “Validate Fix” again
-
🧩 7. Optional – Submit XML Sitemap
-
If URLs are now stable, submit an updated sitemap.xml.
-
This helps Google re-crawl efficiently.
🛡 8. Monitor Ongoing Health
-
Set up:
-
Server uptime monitoring (e.g., UptimeRobot, Pingdom)
-
Application performance monitoring (APM)
-
Error logging/alerts (e.g., Sentry, LogRocket)
-
-
Consider stress testing or using caching/CDN to reduce load.
🚨 Note
If the issue persists, Google may be hitting a different version of the page than you (e.g., mobile vs desktop, or IP-based differences). You may need to:
-
Check for bot blocking or rate limiting
-
Look into dynamic rendering issues if JS-heavy site