What’s your step-by-step approach when valid pages suddenly appear under ‘Excluded by ‘noindex’’ despite no changes in robots meta or HTTP headers?
If valid pages are suddenly appearing under ‘Excluded by ‘noindex’’ in Google Search Console, and you’re sure no changes were made to robots meta tags or HTTP headers, this likely points to a hidden or indirect issue. Here’s a structured, step-by-step approach to diagnose and resolve it:
✅ Step-by-Step Troubleshooting Approach
1. Confirm the Issue in Google Search Console
-
Go to Indexing → Pages → Excluded by ‘noindex’.
-
Export the list of affected URLs.
-
Check how recently they were crawled and when the exclusion was detected.
2. Inspect Sample Pages Using the URL Inspection Tool
For a few sample URLs:
-
Click “Inspect URL” in GSC.
-
Use “View Crawled Page” and “Page indexing” tab:
-
Look at the ‘Indexing allowed?’ and ‘Page fetched successfully?’ fields.
-
Check if the ‘noindex’ directive is present in the crawled version.
-
3. Manually Inspect Pages
Visit several of the reported URLs in a browser and:
🔍 Check:
-
HTML source code:
-
HTTP headers (e.g., via DevTools or
curl -I
):-
Look for:
-
-
Ensure the correct version (desktop/mobile) is being checked.
4. Check for Conditional Output or Cloaking
Even if you didn’t change anything, there might be conditional logic or unintended cloaking:
-
Are different meta tags or headers shown to:
-
Googlebot?
-
Mobile devices?
-
Logged-in vs anonymous users?
-
-
Test using Googlebot’s user-agent or Mobile-Friendly Test tool.
5. Check Template or CMS Logic
Sometimes CMSs dynamically inject meta tags based on page state:
-
Was there a recent plugin/module/theme update?
-
Are pages incorrectly marked as:
-
Expired
-
Drafts
-
Orphans (no internal links)?
-
-
Are there template-level fallbacks inserting
noindex
by default?
6. Review Server-Side Headers
Use tools like:
Or:
Check if:
-
X-Robots-Tag: noindex
is conditionally set -
Any redirect chains introduce it
-
CDN (e.g., Cloudflare, Akamai) injects unexpected headers
7. Look for Recent Changes in Site Infrastructure
Even if meta tags or headers didn’t change:
-
Was the page moved or redirected temporarily (302) to a URL with
noindex
? -
Has canonicalization changed (e.g., canonical now points to a noindexed page)?
-
Have hreflang tags started pointing to noindexed versions?
8. Review JavaScript Rendering
If your site is JavaScript-heavy:
-
Is content (or meta tags) being inserted via JS?
-
Did a rendering error cause the
<meta name="robots" content="noindex">
to be inserted or not removed? -
Use Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test or Rich Results Test to render and analyze.
9. Fix Root Cause
Once identified, correct:
-
Templates injecting incorrect tags
-
Conditional logic errors
-
Server/CDN header misconfigurations
-
Redirect/canonical chains pointing to noindex pages
10. Validate Fix and Monitor
-
Fix the pages and then:
-
Use URL Inspection → “Test Live URL”.
-
If resolved, click “Request Indexing”.
-
-
Monitor GSC over the next few weeks to confirm pages return to indexed status.