Skip to main content

How would you troubleshoot if thousands of URLs are reported as ‘Soft 404s’ after a CMS update?

Troubleshooting thousands of Soft 404 errors after a CMS update requires a structured, thorough approach. Here's how you can go about it:

1. Understand the Issue

Soft 404: A page that appears to be missing (e.g., no meaningful content) but returns a 200 OK status code instead of a 404 or 410.

2. Collect Initial Data

  • Google Search Console → Indexing → Pages → Filter by "Soft 404".

  • Export the full list of affected URLs.

  • Compare against logs or sitemap to determine:

    • If they existed before the CMS update.

    • If they are intentionally removed or changed.

3. Identify Patterns

Analyze the URLs for common traits:

  • Are they in a specific folder (e.g., /blog/, /products/)?

  • Do they share similar templates or parameters?

  • Are they legacy URLs pointing to non-existent resources?

4. Inspect Sample Pages

Manually visit a few affected URLs:

  • Does the page look blank, have thin content, or redirect improperly?

  • Check HTTP headers (e.g., with Chrome DevTools or curl):

    curl -I https://example.com/suspect-url

    Look for:

    • Status code (should not be 200 OK if content is missing).

    • Canonical tags (misconfigured ones can cause issues).

    • Meta noindex or redirects.

5. Review CMS Update Changes

Dive into what the update modified:

  • Templates: Did layout or content population logic change?

  • Routing: Are URLs being routed to the wrong controller/view?

  • Redirects: Did redirect rules get altered or removed?

  • Plugins/Modules: Any new SEO or URL handling plugins added?

6. Common Causes to Check

  • Empty pages still returning 200 OK.

  • Redirects to home page or unrelated content.

  • Missing canonical URLs or canonicalizing to a non-existent page.

  • Session-dependent or JS-generated content failing to load for bots.

  • URL normalization issues (e.g., trailing slashes, case sensitivity).

7. Fixes and Recommendations

Based on your findings:

  • Ensure non-existent pages return 404 or 410.

  • Redirect old URLs to equivalent new content using 301 redirects.

  • Update templates to serve proper content or error codes.

  • Improve thin content pages with meaningful content.

  • Use a custom 404 page to improve UX and signal the right status.

8. Test & Validate

  • Use curl, Screaming Frog, or Google's URL Inspection Tool to verify fixes.

  • Submit corrected URLs for reindexing in Search Console.

  • Monitor progress over the next few crawls.

9. Prevent Future Recurrence

  • Add automated tests or monitoring for HTTP status codes.

  • Maintain a URL mapping table during future CMS updates.

  • Educate devs/content teams about SEO implications of thin content.

Popular posts from this blog

How does BGP prevent routing loops? Explain AS_PATH and loop prevention mechanisms.

 In Border Gateway Protocol (BGP), preventing routing loops is critical — especially because BGP is the inter-domain routing protocol used to connect Autonomous Systems (ASes) on the internet. 🔄 How BGP Prevents Routing Loops The main mechanism BGP uses is the AS_PATH attribute . 🔍 What is AS_PATH? AS_PATH is a BGP path attribute that lists the sequence of Autonomous Systems (AS numbers) a route has traversed. Each time a route is advertised across an AS boundary, the local AS number is prepended to the AS_PATH. Example: If AS 65001 → AS 65002 → AS 65003 is the route a prefix has taken, the AS_PATH will look like: makefile AS_PATH: 65003 65002 65001 It’s prepended in reverse order — so the last AS is first . 🚫 Loop Prevention Using AS_PATH ✅ Core Mechanism: BGP routers reject any route advertisement that contains their own AS number in the AS_PATH. 🔁 Why It Works: If a route makes its way back to an AS that’s already in the AS_PATH , that AS kno...
Read more

What’s the impact of BGP full routes on router memory and performance?

Receiving full BGP routes (i.e., the full global BGP routing table) has a significant impact on a router's memory and performance. Here's a breakdown of the key impacts: 🔧 1. Memory Usage (RAM) A full BGP table typically contains ~1 million IPv4 routes and growing (~200k+ IPv6 routes). Each BGP route consumes tens to hundreds of bytes of memory, depending on attributes (AS path, communities, etc.). This translates to hundreds of megabytes to several gigabytes of RAM just for storing the BGP RIB (Routing Information Base). The FIB (Forwarding Information Base) , which is installed into the router's hardware or kernel for actual packet forwarding, also consumes memory (especially in TCAM for hardware routers). ❗ Example A router might require 4–8 GB of RAM (or more) to comfortably handle full BGP routes with headroom for growth and stability. 🧠 2. CPU Utilization High CPU load during: Initial BGP session establishment (parsing all rout...
Read more

Explain the OSPF LSDB (Link State Database) and how SPF (Shortest Path First) algorithm works.

OSPF (Open Shortest Path First) is a link-state routing protocol , and the LSDB (Link-State Database) and SPF (Shortest Path First) algorithm are core to how OSPF calculates the best paths . Let’s break them down. 🧠 What is the OSPF LSDB (Link-State Database)? The LSDB is a map of the entire OSPF network area — each router stores a complete topology of its area. 🔍 Details: Built from LSAs (Link-State Advertisements) exchanged between routers. Contains info about: Routers and their interfaces Network segments Neighbor relationships Each OSPF router maintains an identical LSDB within the same area. ✅ Key Characteristics: Feature Description Scope One LSDB per OSPF area Source Built from received LSAs Consistency All routers in an area have identical LSDBs Purpose Used as input for SPF algorithm to calculate best paths ⚙️ How the SPF Algorithm Works in OSPF OSPF uses Dijkstra’s Shortest Path First (SPF) algorithm to compute the shortest (lowest-cost)...
Read more